Alan's Thunks

Thursday, February 12, 2026

Do not trust simple solutions and things are complicated?

 

 It is relevant to explain that I am a mathematician. One of the things about mathematics is that you sometimes get things wrong. This seems to be a problem in the world of politics and even when you know you're wrong and admit it, you get criticised for being wrong, not praised for being honest.

The other important lesson it is possible to learn from mathematics is that often the soution to a problem is complicated. Therev are two differnt ways this can happen. One is to show that the answer is right but also sometimes the answer is complicated. To illustrate with an example from an area that I have worked in. There are some objects which are called "Finite simple groups". In this context it does not  matter what they are but what does matter is that nearly all of them have nice coeherent descriptions except for 26 examples. This is fact. The descriptions are complicated and, when using the descriptions, these 26 exceptions have to be considered. It is irritating but illustrates the point: life is not simple.

This is why I never trust anyone who tells me that have a simple solution to a problem. Or even that they have a solution. It would be comforting if there were people who were so talented we could trust them to solve all our problems. I am sure there are some people who can solve some problems some of the time; doctors can cure some illnesses but not always. Plumbers can mend some plumbing problems but we would not expect them to cure cancer. Which leads me to wonder why people follow individuals who claim that they have solutions and everything will magically get better. 

There are too many examples today, from Trump and Farage on the right to Corbyn and Polanski who are more on the left. It is not just the individuals but those who put so much hope into them. The problem is that there are those who put their faith into "simple" solutions, whether it be religious or political beliefs. Tax the rich, let the market decide, be a christian/hindu/islamic country and all our problems will be solved.

Surely it must be clear that this is nonsense, is it just that we want to believe there are simple solutions! 

 

 

 

 

Labels: ,

Sunday, November 28, 2010

Happines

Some of you will know that the British Prime Minister is spending money to find out what makes us happy, presumably not including drugs, sex & rock and roll.

My simple view was the following recipe:-

(A) Knowing what you want to do

(B) Being able to do it

There should be a third

(C) Minimizing the amount of time doing things you don't like

However my daughter replied

"you may be looking at the happiness thing all wrong - which seems likely given that it is David Cameron's idea. I think 'happiness' is momentary, or situational at least. I think the question is 'content' which I think the PM can't use because we align contentment with lack of drive and/or ambition ' content with your lot' is considered a bad thing, where as being happy is considered good.

But I think it is a more relevant question, I can be very unhappy at this moment, something sad may have happened, but I am overall content. And I agree, knowing what you want and being able to go for it is a key thing in making one content, but knowing you need food and knowing you need to go and queue at a homeless shelter to get it?

We need to think of Maslov's hierarchy of needs (unfortunately), I think there s a point at which poverty and ill health do impact on happiness, although I accept 'money doesn't buy you happiness'."

This moves the original simplistic observation onto a new level.

Labels: